Mateship, Baggy Green and dirty laundry

Usman Khawaja's recent revelation may have come as a promise to stand by his old mate David Warner; but in doing so, has he let his other mates down?
Mateship.
It’s not an Australian invention. It’s not an Australian concept. It’s not even solely an Australian ‘thing’. Even if it is the most Australian of things.
Mainly, because of how often it’s brought up here. It is officially considered an Australian value. One that you are expected to imbibe and practice if you want to be accepted as an Australian.
So much so that, it’s part of their citizenship test. It’s one of the five ‘value’ questions that you cannot get wrong among the 20 you are made to answer.
And one of the overwhelming yet underrated narratives around Australian cricket’s implosion over the return of Sandpapergate over the last 10 days has been the dramatic explosion of that very mateship. Especially since it involves a bunch of former teammates, who spent a decade-and-a-half proudly donning their Baggy Greens, now throwing barbs at each other.
Unfortunately, they’re only getting more personal by the day. Both publicly and behind the scenes. As the emotions continue to run high across all camps in this rapidly developing divide between the current and the recent past.
Behind all the back and forth, all the bad blood, behind all the “he said, he said, how I remember what was said,” lies the sad state of fractured relationships. With the lashing out from both sides now meaning that the rest are forced into a position to pick sides.
To the extent you wonder if Sandpapergate hasn’t become incidental over the last week. And if the recall of events from Newlands 2018 from eight and a half years ago haven’t simply become the trigger for what’s been simmering below the surface for so long.
How else do you explain the complete breakdown of that ‘mateship’, which those now firing volleys at each other would have shared in dressing-rooms around the world. Cummins and Khawaja alone played in 74 matches across formats for Australia. That’s a lot of time spent together in dressing-rooms and lot of time being mates, on and off the field.
It’s been equally fascinating about how surprised a large section of the cricket world outside Australia has been by the soap opera nature of what many have described as Australian cricket’s civil war. “Since when does Australian cricket indulge in this level of Bollywood-style family melodrama,” is one of the queries posed repeatedly over the last 10 days.
As is the case in these situations, at a time when the discourse has revolved around throwing your former teammates under the bus, there has been no dearth of expert voices jumping on the bus to give their opinions, mostly unsolicited, mainly extreme. From questioning Cummins’ integrity and how tenable his captaincy reign remains to the never-ending conspiracy theories around why Khawaja would have chosen to reengage the ghosts of South African tours past. Even as many of the other lead and walk-on characters from that tour have chosen to either stay silent or not get pulled into sharing their recollections, save former seamer, Chadd Sayers.
At no point through this process, however, has it felt like there would be any kind of closure at hand for any of the parties involved. Purely because a lot of the finger-pointing has centred around very subjective recollections of a forgettable chain of events that most have tried to move on from at different levels. Except those worst affected by it, David Warner in particular, who has had to deal with the very tiresome tag of having been the criminal mastermind behind one of Australian cricket’s worst scandals. Speaking of overreactions.
What all those recollections have lacked interestingly enough are the real ‘details’. Even if ‘details’ is a word used quite incessantly by every one of the lead voices who’ve made their feelings known on the issue. Cummins, Khawaja and Warner included.
Even Sayers, who of the lot provided the most details but again mainly to do with his own involvement in the matter. But like the rest, his rather courageous stance too included a lot of “should haves” and “must haves”.
“….there are big leaps here where he’s being vague, and the details really matter because it affects real people, affects people’s lives,” was one of Cummins’ strongest lines in his 68-minute press conference last Friday in Sydney.
But it’s true of pretty much every version of events we’ve heard during this seemingly unquenchable quest for the “truth” as Warner put it. And it’s safe to assume that around the margins of these unclarified details perhaps lie the real truth, the real story. For, as of now, there’s every reason to believe that every man who’s spoken on the matter so far sincerely believes that it’s the truest recall.
So, we’re left with a bunch of strong-willed men who at some levels insist that they have been wronged but are even more insistent that they are right. Cameron Bancroft is expected to give his ‘detailed’ take sometime soon on his version of events. But you still wonder if there’ll be enough there for anyone to prove or disprove what the others in disagreement with his version say really happened.
That brings us to Khawaja’s book, Sabr. It is a remarkable autobiography, easily among the rawest and most authentic of reads you can expect from a retired athlete. But it’s also written like a stream of conscience in which a thoughtful man has chosen to unleash his innermost thoughts in an unabashed fashion rarely seen in this genre. It is a unique reflection piece on one of the most unique journeys in cricket history. By the time you get to Chapter 17, and he takes the reader back to South Africa, you’ve been introduced to a young man who’s throughout his life been on a journey of self-exploration with regards to every aspect of his life. His background, his family, his faith, his beliefs, his religion and his own mind.
So, his narration of how he remembers things going down on that ill-fated South African tour is the next chapter of this inner dialogue he continues to battle with throughout the book. He reiterates his rationale for bringing it all up as being a promise he made to his childhood friend, Warner, in a bid to find justice for how it impacted his former opening partner’s life and reputation. But he does so in a way where he shares enough new information for it to have become the talk of the cricket world without ever shining too bright a light on any particular detail that directly brings any individual into the spotlight.
And it eventually all comes back to 'mateship'. Standing up for yourself over standing by your mate.
In one corner, we have Khawaja and Warner with some support now from Sayers trying to shine a light on what they believe mateship should have looked like in this particular case, as in the entire team taking collective responsibility for whatever transpired in reality back in 2018. On the other hand, there’s Cummins, and his bowling cohort by association, questioning Khawaja’s mateship and if a friend really would be so “casual and flippant” about a mate’s life.
But like everything else in this unfortunate episode, it remains one man’s version versus the other, with no light at the end of this tunnel of unrequited mateship.




